Crafty COWGIRL: Peppermint Cake Pops


If you haven’t already embraced the holiday season, this recipe is sure to get you in the spirit. We’ve all seen the classic horse treats with the peppermint in the center, but have you ever seen a cake pop made specially for horses? Follow along the recipe below and bake some delicious snacks for your four-legged friend this winter. 

Peppermint Cake Pops

Yields 18 cake pops


  • 3 cups oat bran 
  • 1 cup applesauce
  • 1 cup chopped carrots
  • 1 cup quick oats
  • 1 cup molasses 
  • 1 cup flax seeds (great for your horse’s hair!)
  • ½ cup all-purpose flour
  • 18 peppermint candy sticks 
  • Cake pop pan (18-slot preferred)
  • Large mixing bowls
  • Cooling rack


  1. Preheat oven to 300°.
  2. Mix dry ingredients together in large mixing bowl (does not include carrots). 
  3. Mix in the molasses, applesauce and carrots.
  4. Spray each cake pop pan with cooking spray, especially with metal pans. 
  5. Fill both the top and bottom cake pop pans with your mixture. Fill the side with the hole a little less full, so that there’s room to put your peppermint stick in later steps. 
  6. Flip pan with hole onto the top of the other pan. 
  7. Take one of the peppermint sticks and make a hole in each of the cake pops before putting into the oven. Make sure that your peppermint stick is removed before putting into the oven.
  8. Bake for 1 hour. You can take the baking time to unwrap the rest of the peppermint sticks so that they’re ready once the pops are baked.
  9. Remove from oven and carefully remove the top tray, revealing the pops with holes in the top. 
  10. After allowing them to cool for ten minutes, gently insert the peppermint sticks into the hole of each cake pop. It’s crucial to let them cool slightly first! Otherwise your peppermint sticks will start to melt. Don’t wait too long though, or they won’t stick to the inside of the cake pops! Timing is crucial.
  11. Let the pops sit in the pan for another 15 minutes before pulling them from the pan. 
  12. Place finished pops on the cooling rack and adjust peppermint sticks as needed. 
  13. Allow the pops to cool completely and stiffen just slightly before feeding. Then share with all your favorite horsey friends!


Read More

Top It Off: Our Favorite Charlie 1 Horse Hats For Spring

Top It Off: Our Favorite Charlie 1 Horse Hats For Spring

photography courtesy of You know that feeling when the sunshine hits your face for the first time in months? Yeah. We want to bottle that euphoric feeling and infuse it into our closet this spring. Bring on color, texture, light layers, and all...

Stetson Wright Looks To Come Back Stronger Than Ever

Stetson Wright Looks To Come Back Stronger Than Ever

The eight-time world champion and all-around cowboy has become a household name at the young age of 24 and has no intentions of letting injuries slow him down. After a devastating hamstring injury took him out early in the 2023 National Finals Rodeo, Stetson Wright...

Related Posts

Music On Mondays: Week Of 2/19/24

Music On Mondays: Week Of 2/19/24

Lainey Wilson's new single "Country's Cool Again" “This track is an ode to my upbringing and the story of my journey in this industry – where I have been and where I am now. I’m feeling all the love from Country music fans,...